Home | Help | Site Map | Contact Us
Divorce Support Forums: Father Knows Best
The Mens Rights Manual for Divorce The Men’s Rights Manual for Divorce ($49.95)
This is the best investment a man can make when the threat of divorce becomes inevitable.
Available by Mail and Download
You are not logged in.
[Login]
[Register Here]
Main Index · Search Forums · Active Topics
New User Registration · Who's Online · FAQ · Calendar

General Forums >> Men's Rights
Previous topic Previous   View all topics Index   Next topic Next   Threaded Mode Threaded  

Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | >> (show all)
gigi
Platinum
***

Reged: 11/06/06
Posts: 5138
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: jbar]
      #211894 - 06/13/08 02:41 AM (68.110.66.68)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

How did this turn from a decent thread about how to progress away from Dads being viewed as buffoons and abusive, so that maybe they can return to being real dads, getting a full share of time with the children, and having a healthier society overall related to parenting issues, into a thread accusing women of being gold-diggers and taking your possessions via community property law? Just becasue you said so? Are you so narrow in yoru focus that you can not allow a thread about what it takes to be a good father to go without your personal campaign against community property somehow getting inserted into it?

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
malone
Platinum
***

Reged: 12/30/07
Posts: 2026
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: gigi]
      #211896 - 06/13/08 06:40 AM (222.152.66.30)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

[quote]How did this turn from a decent thread ... into a thread accusing women of being gold-diggers and taking your possessions via community property law? [/quote]


Oh I can help you with the answer to that Gigi. It's simple. Because Jbar has an unnatural, irrational dislike of women that at times verges on paranoia that ALL women are quote: "financial rapists"...amongst all the other things he has referred to women as.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
stoltz
Platinum
**

Reged: 01/29/07
Posts: 1493
Loc: Texas
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: gigi]
      #211943 - 06/13/08 11:06 AM (32.97.110.142)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

Not sure about other Latin countries, but I've heard that Mexico is WORSE than the USA when it comes to issues such as DV, Men's Rights vs. Women's Rights, child support/custody, etc. Again, something I've only heard, but not researched.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
stoltz
Platinum
**

Reged: 01/29/07
Posts: 1493
Loc: Texas
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: malone]
      #211946 - 06/13/08 11:13 AM (32.97.110.142)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

I can't speak for Jbar, but I think a lot of his angst is similar to mine in that it isn't so much a 'woman against man' issue as it is a 'government/society against man' in which (1) women are given more of an opportunity to become "financial rapists", etc., and (2) men are more apt to have their constitutional rights violated simply because of their gender.

But I could be wrong.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
gigi
Platinum
***

Reged: 11/06/06
Posts: 5138
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: stoltz]
      #211952 - 06/13/08 11:45 AM (68.110.66.68)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

I understnad being frustrated at your constitutional rights being violated... though JBar has always ALSO framed it in the "women = evil, women want all our money and the government lets them get it" kind of way...

My current frustration is at the fact that there's almost never a thread in DivorceSupport forum which deals with father's issues, where he doesn't put in his two cents about property.

There are a numbers of father's rights groups which actually discuss father's rights without trying to confront their own personal concerns about money. I even know one group where, if you post on there with a complaint about how child support is sucking you dry and you need to get out of it... they'll slam you with questions about how often you're seeing the kid and whether you're thinking of the child's needs or just your own desire for a new... whatever. These are GUYS doing the slamming (I know some of them personally), and they get VERY frustrated when they see someone coming online to make a stereotypical complaint against financial issues when the issue they're trying to confront is how to be a good father in a separated household. And how to get the courts to ALLOW them to become that.

I'm frustrated that the DivorceSUpport forum, because JBar just won't let it be, can never have a discussion of parenting by fathers, without having his personal issue of community property enter into it. I've seen him advise fathers who wanted to find a way to get more time with thier kid, on how to divert thier money to an offshore acount and/or move away (from the kid) to a country where they'll get the house in a divorce (he's not figured out that you can't force a divorce decree in a foreign country to be honored by a property recorder's office here... but that's another issue).

If someone popped in that that kind of inane talk to poor fathers who probably do NOT have lots of cash to hide in offshore accounts, who are struggling to make ends meet and figure out how to spend time with the kids while working 3 jobs to pay for RAISING them... well... he'd be flamed off the boards there.

This forum has many more resources, much broder information base... members who are on other sides of an issue, so a discussion of father's issues would be very valuable for the insights that some others could provide on it... But if we keep insisting on diverting every conversation about men's issues into property saving conversations... well, it's almost become comical, it's that ridiculous. JBar has become a charicature... well, he became that a long time ago... a constitutionalist (which I am one, so don't shoot me for saying that... I'm just not a charicature of one)... isolationist, deadbeat, emotionally abusive man who thinks up ways to get his wife committed so she won't take his precious income earned during the marriage.

I am surprised that the men of this forum never speak up the way they do on that other forum, and tell men who say, "I impregnated a girl and now she turned out to be a bad mother, how do I get out of paying child supprot"... to go fly a kite because men like him make the rest of you look bad. I'm wishing that the men on this forum would stand up and say, "Jbar, shut up already. If you don't want a woman to share your stuff, don't marry her, or divorce her as soon as you figure out that you value your stuff more than her. You're making the rest of us who want to do right by our exes look like jerks, and attitudes like yours make it harder for good people to get the right thing to happen in the courts.".

I'm just surprised that one one but me has ever said that attitudes like his hurt the whole cause... that ONE person who is that vocal and wrong-minded and money-grubbing can undo 100 guys who walk into court and do NOT try to hide money, cheat their wives, embarass them into silence or send them to live in a third world contry with no means of support.

OK, I'm just frustrated today... having read some wonderful views of fathers who really want to keep the focus on good fathering, who, if they succeed, will do WONDERS for all the other issues you have otu there...

I mean, you DO know that if the father's rights group get the 50-50% shared parenting plans to be the norm in this country, that there will no longer be the huge disparities in what women take out of a divorce versus what men take? Becasue women will be told to go back to work... that they have JUST as much time and opportunity to get good jobs... that the men have JUST as much right to the marital home for teh kids to live in 50% of the time... that the men have JUST as much right to the furniture, cloting, etc...

YOu DO know that political movement, REAL political movement, starts with people who resolve the most inequitable, easiest to sympathize with issue... and the fatherhood issue, the shared parenting one... IS the most sympathetic because in this country where everything is "for the children", it's a good idea to align yourself with what's in the children's best intersts, and the job is as small as making everyone understadn how important fathers are? You DO understand that the cause of a guy wanting to keep everything that was acquired during th emarriage and tossing his wife out on her ear is not exactly as sympathetic?

Sigh... Sorry... Just frustrated that a good thread was hijacked...


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
stoltz
Platinum
**

Reged: 01/29/07
Posts: 1493
Loc: Texas
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: gigi]
      #211956 - 06/13/08 12:02 PM (32.97.110.142)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

Not to ignore your response, but I was listening on the AM radio this am. The show is basically a run-of-the-mill news show. The discussion at hand had nothing whatsoever to do with divorce, custody, support, etc. I can;t recall if it was one of the DJ's, a guest, or someone calling in, but a guy basically said he had the "average rural Texas" values and if could do nothing else, he'd bring all the fathers who are behind on child support to the town square and "hang 'em all." He didn't have an angry tone and I guess he just had some beef about it from something he's read (or maybe has a female relative who isn't getting CS), but it REALLY made me think of just how out-of-touch a lot of people - EVEN MEN - are about the whole child support issue. Yes, there probably ARE *MEN* (notice it was "MEN" and not people) who have the means to pay CS but purposely don't. But that's a VERY, VERY small percentage of not only divorced fathers, but of men who are behind, period.

A'las, such a long way to go.

EDIT: I remember now, the topic on the show was what you would do on Father's Day if you could. That's when the guy made his statement.

Edited by stoltz (06/13/08 01:08 PM)


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
allthumbs
Platinum
***

Reged: 07/12/07
Posts: 560
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: stoltz]
      #211969 - 06/13/08 01:06 PM (76.21.84.87)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

Divorce is financially difficult on both parties, the husband and the wife. Many of us may come from very average and modest backgrounds and occupations. I agree it is paramount that the NCP contributes substantially to the financial welfare of his/her children, but the NCP should not be "criminalized" by the family court if they cannot provide an exorbitant amount ordered by the court. In my case, the court declared I made $5,000.00 a month, even though I supplied two years of tax returns showing my income to be less. Just because the court could, and thought that's what I should earn. They imputed my ex's income with minimum wage, even though she had actually earned nearly $20.00 per hour. IMO, that's a "sexist" decision and I'd agree the family court is still, for the most part, gender biased.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
stoltz
Platinum
**

Reged: 01/29/07
Posts: 1493
Loc: Texas
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: allthumbs]
      #211972 - 06/13/08 01:19 PM (32.97.110.142)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

I agree, in most cases divorce is a financial smack to the face for both parties. What troubles me is what you mentioned in the 2nd-half of your post. Most of the laws and judgements received WRT Family Law arises from (usually erroneous and/or not fully disclosed) data that is introduced from a heavily-biased source - mostly women/feminist groups. Granted, there have been some strides WRT custody and support, but most still live by the original concept. For example, many/most? states still want the children to have the same financial lifestyle pre-divorce, but fail to consider that there are now TWO households to support, which further puts the burden on the parents.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
EZmark
Platinum
**

Reged: 06/04/07
Posts: 292
Loc: Florida
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: gigi]
      #212032 - 06/13/08 05:16 PM (64.178.162.154)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

I know you'd like to have a philosophically pure discussion, but unfortunately it is not possible to seperate all the other issues from the "being a good father" because the situation many if not most divorced fathers live in daily is affected by many factors but especially property loss, CS & alimony obligations VS survival, and loss of children. Victims have a different perspective, not as understanding. It is hard to discus abstracts while tied to the whipping post. If jbar is a characture ie:atypical of what becomes of many: one has to wonder what made him that way. I think you know.

Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
gigi
Platinum
***

Reged: 11/06/06
Posts: 5138
Re: Father Knows Best [Re: EZmark]
      #212051 - 06/13/08 07:17 PM (68.110.66.68)
Edit post Edit   Reply to this post Reply   Reply to this post Quote   Quick Reply Quick Reply  

Geez EZ, the charicature of JBar was NOT caused by any actual experience with the system. He is NOT a father and not a stepfather. He does not live with his wife and has no interest in divorcing her because he fears the law. He cannot get a lawyer to promise him that he'll get everything, so he is consumed with ways of figuring out how to intimidate her into not filing.

And if you saw some of his tactics I think you'd also be fleeing from his defense. He has threatened to falsely accuse her of things and have her committed to an insane asylum (she's a foreigner so she has only a vague understanding of the laws and does not know that this is not as likely to happen as he claims). She works and he lives off disability, having fought hard for it (so you know it's not a CLEAR physical disability, but rather had a severe mental component, you know?)... and getting a lump sum for back disability pay. He used his settlement to buy some properties. She kept working. He fears that she'll lay claim to some portion of his properties, so he figured out how to convince her to go home to spend time with her dying mother in her homeland, and not return. For YEARS.

HE's never actually availed himself of the laws, but his fear of it (from having read alarmist stories off bunches of blogs) makes him act like this. He has no actual experience with the divorce laws at all which cause him to feel this way, ONLY his conjecture and his interesting, rather skewed view of things. He actually believes that his wife would never be able to have an atotrney represent her in court. He believes any atotrney doing so woudl be unethical. He says it's because he has proof that she's schizophrenic and it's against legal ethics to represent a mentally ill person. THe twists & turns of logic he took to get to this conclusion were amazing, and as a result, he advised his wife on this law and convinced her that eh was right, so that if she dared to tak ehim to court, she'd lose it all.

She has never demanded anythign from him, has not lived with him in YEARS (if at all, they maintained separate households even when amicably married, to hear him tell it), and has been living on her own all this time. She did have a business which failed and he feared terribly that she woudl demand half of his for that... but it's been a few years and so far, nothing. There was a point where he heard she was back in the country and had a car. I don't recall what the issue was but he wanted to prevent her from driving it and had twisted himself into all kinds of logical contortions, something involving deporting her or something...

I mean, this guy has nothing to do with community property law other than fear mongering... so when he decides to show up in EVERY thread involving fatherhood and tries to hijack it...

Well, I've seen other forums where the fahters actually kept control of each other adn didn't spend all thier time patting each other on the backs for coming up with new and more extremist points of view... and it's frustrating to see that on htis forum where there are so many good guys, none of you are speaking up to tell him to just suck it up & get it over with and stop trying to make men look like jerks by trying to mess up thier wives...


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | >> (show all)


Previous topic Previous   View all topics Index   Next topic Next   Threaded Mode Threaded  

Extra information
0 registered and 5 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:   

Print Topic

Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      UBBCode is disabled

Rating:
Topic views: 1456

Rate this topic

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement Divorce Support Forums

Powered by UBB.threads™ 6.5.2